This week, we’re checking ourselves into Arkham. Someone is killing off public figures (again), Jim and Barbara update their relationship status, and we finally get to the bottom of the corruption in Gotham: office supply thievery. Meanwhile, Fish Mooney is putting her own spin on American Idol and Penguin earns himself a promotion. April struggles to find a positive in how the show is treating women, Billy theorizes about a future use for the killer’s weapon, and Jon wonders how six extra episodes will affect the structure of the season. But does this episode earn our vote or does it belong in the toxic waste dump? Listen and find out!